CASE ANALYSIS
After that they went to the metro station where the sad incident occurred and there they saw the video footage of the day in which the Nabin died. They saw nothing different from what David told them. On the next day Nakul, Ellias and Barsha were sitting in Nakul’s house analyzing and evaluating the various evidence that they have obtained from various sources.
Barsha then said, “I think, it is Indrajit who is the murderer of Irfan. He might be taking revenge of his brother’s death as in his eyes David, Irfan and Ashutosh are responsible for his brother’s death and if unfortunately I am correct, then David and Ashutosh will be his next victim.”
Ellias said, “No beer, I think it is something else than revenge. I think it is all a plan and it is designed by none other than Nabin’s parents. You see that Nabin had an insurance policy amount of Rs.75,00,000.00 after whose death the amount will accrue to his parents. Irfan was Nabin’s brother whom Nabin’s parents had asked to look after them and moreover in the video footage of the metro station we saw that it was Irfan who pushed Nabin and now Irfan is dead. It all gives some indications towards Nabin’s parents. I am of the opinion that Nabin’s parents must have told Irfan to kill him in such a manner that it should look like an accident and they might also have promised to give him a share of the policy amount and Irfan must have agreed to the nasty plan.”
Barsha then asked him, “Why is it then Nabin only? Indrajit also had a policy amount of the same value.”
Nakul was silently listening to their opinion when until he answered Barsha’s question.
He said, “I think Indrajit is also involved in all this. This is because Nabin was a member of the Board of Directors and Indrajit was only a sub ordinate employee of the company. It might be due to jealousy. Moreover while Mr. David was providing us with the case details he said that Indrajit always wanted him to call him as his big brother. It gives some indications towards his dominating nature. You only think that why he will only on that particular day forgot his umbrella in the shop.”
As soon as Nakul uttered the word “umbrella” , Barsha said excitingly, “Oh my GOD. The video footage.that we saw in the metro station when Indrajit came and when Mr. David was telling him about the entire incident, there was no umbrella in his hand. I think it was all planned and it was all for the huge policy amount. Bloody money.”
Ellias then asked, “If it was all planned, then, why Irfan was killed? He was also a member of the plan.”
Nakul answered, “It might be because that Nabin’s parents did not want any trail to be left. Those who can murder their own son for money can also kill any other people in order to hide the real truth. Moreover Mr. David told us that Indrajit was the first person to go and call Irfan and after some time when David got there with Ashutosh, he found Irfan dead. It gives some indications towards Indrajit and thereby to his parents also. But how to prove it? This is because they know that a statement without proof is a statement in vain.”
ANOTHER ATTACK
While they were sitting in Nakul’s house analysing and evaluating the various evidence, suddenly the phone rang. It was Mr. David John on the other side. He was sounding very tensed and nervous. He said BEN to come and meet him as quickly as possible at his house and without giving a single explanation for his statement, he disconnected the telephone line. BEN also without wasting a single moment of time quickly took a bus and went to David’ s house and on arriving there he asked what happened and why did he call them.
He said that there has been an attack on Ashutosh. BEN asked him that what makes him make such a comment. He said that he came to know of the fact while he called Ashutosh and he heard a scream of Ashutosh in the phone on the other side. Therefore he called them. David and BEN then went to Ashutosh’s residence. In the mean time the police and ambulance had arrived there. Ashutosh therein was in a very serious condition, just struggling between life and death. They enquired the police as to what happened to him but they did not answer or respond properly.
David went with him in the ambulance and BEN entered the house of Ashutosh. Ellias saw something in the house and he said that his search is over and they need to go back home. Nakul and Barsha did not understand him but they without questioning him followed Ellias back home. After coming back to Nakul’ house when Nakul asked him, he answered, “I think the person who attacked Ashutosh was none but David himself.”
They were shocked to hear that. Barsha then asked him, “What makes you make such a comment?”
Ellias looked at her and answered, “Do you want to know what did I see there in Ashutosh’s house?”
Nakul and Barsha nodded his head indicating that they want to know. Ellias said that when he entered Ashutosh’s house he saw a piece of cigerratte in the floor. Ellias then said,
“Now, tell me guys, who is the only person involved in this case who smokes?”
Nakul and Barsha answered instantaneously, “David John.”
Ellias said, “Yes. Correct.”
They remembered very clearly that when they first met Mr. David John in the dock, he was smoking a cigerratte and watching time in his titan watch. Ellias continued, “Think, why would he give a murder case to a new detective agency BEN, who does not have any past experience or good past record. Why?”
Nakul then said, “Whoever might be the murderer, if Ashutosh is saved by the doctors in the hospital then there will be another attack on him as the murderer would want to remove all the trails.” So BEN without wasting a single moment of time went to the hospital in which Ashutosh was taken.
THE PLAN
So the trio quickly went to the hospital. David was also there present. They without even meeting David there went straight to the doctor and said that whatever might be the condition of Ashutosh, he should tell David and all other that Ashutosh is out of danger, though not in sense and he will be discharged tomorrow after giving his statement to the police authority. If anyone wants to meet him, then the doctor should say that he will not be able to meet anybody unless the police comes and meets him and takes his statement in a proper manner.
The doctor at first totally refused to the proposal but when the trio told him that they are doing so in order to catch the real culprit, the doctor with some sort of unsatisfaction accepted the proposal. The doctor did exactly as per the plan. Now BEN told David to go to his office and they will look after him properly. So, David went to the office and now BEN has a plan. BEN at first went to Nabin and Indrajit Malpani’s parents’s residence and told them that there has been an attack on Ashutosh but the doctors have managed to save him and now the only wait is for the sunrise of the next day when the police will come and take the statement of Ashutosh and the culprit behind all these attacks will be unmasked. After that they went to Indrajit’s house and they told him the same.
After that they went to INDEX TOOLS. On arriving there they saw something strange. They did not understand the reason for which the party is going on. Ellias went there and he asked ANaina Singh, the same girl with whom Ellias made friendship in order to get the information out of her and from whom he came to know of the story of insurance policy. ANaina said that owing to the death of Nabin Malpani and Irfan Ahmed and due to the temporary incapability of Mr. Ashutosh Chakraborty, Mr. David John has been appointed as the new member of the Board of Directors. That is why a party is going on in order to celebrate.
They were a bit surprised and their suspicion towards David grew stronger. So BEN also went there and announced that though there has been an attack on Ashutosh, the doctors have managed to save him and he will be discharged soon. But still now he is in the hospital. Actually BEN wanted the others to know that Ashutosh has survived the attack because if the murderer is among them then the murderer will again try to kill him and that is how the murderer will be caught.
To Continue Click on Page Below…
